American Idol

Post by **SMLCHNG** » April 4, 2007 10:50 pm

The three guys that left the stage.. should have been the bottom 3.

Gina wasn't the 'best', but she had a nicer voice that some that stayed. I think that unfortunately her tongue ring MIGHT have distracted some.

Thank goodness for Melinda.

Bob Roberts · Post by **Bob Roberts** » April 5, 2007 6:31 am

My wife is p***! Gina was her favorite. Haley is getting the same votes that Antonella got. Every fat ugly loser sitting at home that gets a chubby when she is on stage in her skirt calls in and votes for her. Come on guys.......BUY A PLAYBOY!..........this is a SINGING competition!

TommyBahama · Post by **TommyBahama** » April 5, 2007 7:08 am

i have nothing to add...this is the 1st year i've actually watched....could be my last.....it has to be rigged!!!.....i just don't get the voting!!

NYCsharkling · Post by **NYCsharkling** » April 5, 2007 12:38 pm

I am so done with this show....

Gina was my favorite....

she was so much better than those "no talent ass-clowns" (name the movie).....

Hopefully if Sanjia wins, simon will close down the show for good. It's gone on way too long.

East Texas Parrothead · Post by **East Texas Parrothead** » April 5, 2007 1:06 pm

NYCsharkling wrote:I am so done with this show....

Gina was my favorite....

she was so much better than those "no talent ass-clowns" (name the movie).....

Hopefully if Sanjia wins, simon will close down the show for good. It's gone on way too long.

wNYCs about being so done ... no more for me ... I have to write about it for the paper this season, but not next year ... Nope. I'm out.

LIPH · Post by **LIPH** » April 5, 2007 1:11 pm

Bob Roberts wrote:..........this is a SINGING competition!

The music is the hook the producers used to get the show on TV but all it's ever been is a popularity contest.

East Texas Parrothead · Post by **East Texas Parrothead** » April 5, 2007 1:24 pm

OMG. Larry. That avatar ...

PhutureMD · Post by **PhutureMD** » April 6, 2007 12:50 am

NYCsharkling wrote:I am so done with this show....

Gina was my favorite....

she was so much better than those "no talent ass-clowns" (name the movie).....
Hopefully if Sanjia wins, simon will close down the show for good. It's gone on way too long.

Office Space

habourgirl · Post by **habourgirl** » April 6, 2007 6:50 am

Gina was my favorite too... I know people love Melinda, but to me she's not going to make me go out and buy her album. Gina stands out because she's different. Same thing with Blake. Those 2 are not cookie cutters of every other artist on the radio today.

I'm sooooo sad that Gina left..... I know she probably wasn't going to win, but there are many people who should have left before she did.... So sad.

Bob Roberts · Post by **Bob Roberts** » April 6, 2007 10:52 pm

Melinda will sell more CDs than all the other contestants combined. She has more talent than all of them combined!

iuparrothead · Post by **iuparrothead** » April 10, 2007 11:21 pm

Bob Roberts wrote:Melinda will sell more CDs than all the other contestants combined. She has more talent than all of them combined!

I'll give you that second statement, but I strongly doubt the first. She has a ridiculous amount of talent, but I don't think she has the mass appeal that will lead to record sales. I think Jordin and Blake are the only ones with solid commercial appeal that would translate into lots of interest in their potential recording & performing career.

But anyway... who would have thought Chris & Blake would have gotten the best reviews tonight? I thought LaKisha was solid though. Otherwise, the performances tonight were definitely lacking. Haley looked straight up prostitute.

My predictions are Haley, Phil & Sanjaya in the bottom three (again)... and I'm thinking Haley finally goes. I was so wrong last week so I'm not altogether confident in this prediction, but I wanted to make one anyway.

pojo · Post by **pojo** » April 10, 2007 11:31 pm

IMO, this week, no one really step forward

Post by **SMLCHNG** » April 10, 2007 11:36 pm

I agree with you Ann.

I give up trying to predict this year.

But my feelings and thoughts...

Melinda - Reminded me of a James Bond song. I enjoyed it.

Lakisha - Fun, not WOW, but good.

Chris - Uh, no. Not for me. Too many 'off' notes, and the music drowned him out.

Haley - Lots of energy, very good, then too many whooo hooo's at the end. I think Simon got this one right.

Phil - Lose the hats. Didn't do much for me.

Jordin - Really liked her energy and fun. She's so cute, and has a strong voice.

Blake - Again - I was distracted by his hat, but I liked his singing!

Sanjaya. Well, his hair was better, and the singing wasn't as hideous as other performances.

Jennifer Lopez - I have always liked her. She's cute, and had some good advice for everyone.

Post by **SMLCHNG** » April 10, 2007 11:37 pm

pojo wrote:IMO, this week, no one really step forward

Agreed.

TommyBahama · Post by **TommyBahama** » April 11, 2007 6:59 am

i agree with what Anne said also!!.....But Haley i think is the most marketable due to her looks!!I like Jordon the best.. and think she is cute...but she doesn't have the same sex appeal Haley Has!!.Melinda & Lakisha...best voices...but remind me of a lounge act......As for the guys I think Phil may be in a little trouble!!!....well and Sanjaya...not even going there....because I've been wrong all along!!!

kitty · Post by **kitty** » April 11, 2007 7:38 am

SMLCHNG wrote:Jennifer Lopez - I have always liked her. She's cute, and had some good advice for everyone.

I'd do her!

TommyBahama · Post by **TommyBahama** » April 11, 2007 8:04 am

kitty wrote:
SMLCHNG wrote:Jennifer Lopez - I have always liked her. She's cute, and had some good advice for everyone.
I'd do her!

in a heartbeat.....can i watch??????

Zuke · Post by **Zuke** » April 11, 2007 8:19 am

I'm in for 150 Sanjaya votes, I had to do a little extra last night, I'd knock JLO out if I could, she's a worse singer than Sanjaya.

TommyBahama · Post by **TommyBahama** » April 11, 2007 8:23 am

Zuke wrote:I'm in for 150 Sanjaya votes, I had to do a little extra last night, I'd knock JLO out if I could, she's a worse singer than Sanjaya.

i hope they charge you per vote!!!

Post by **SMLCHNG** » April 11, 2007 8:27 am

kitty wrote:
SMLCHNG wrote:Jennifer Lopez - I have always liked her. She's cute, and had some good advice for everyone.
I'd do her!

Can't argue with that!!