BuffettNews.com

Vote for whichever song you like better
The poll will be open for 48 hours.

(2) Fins:
http://www.buffettnews.com/song63.html

Written By: Jimmy Buffett, Deborah McColl, B.Chance, Tom Corcoran

Discography:
Volcano (1979)
Songs You Know By Heart (1985)
Live by the Bay (1986)
Feeding Frenzy (1990)
Boats, Beaches, Bars & Ballads (1992)
Biloxi: Best of (1999)
Buffett Live - Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays (1999)
Meet Me In Margaritaville (2003)
Live in Auburn, WA (2003)
Live in Las Vegas, NV (2003)
Minimatinee 1 (2003)
Live in Mansfield, MA (2004)
Live in Cincinnati, OH (2004)
Live In Hawaii (2005)
Live at Fenway Park (2005)
Live at Wrigley Field (2006)
From the Big Apple to the Big Easy - the concert for New Orleans (2006)

Total Times Played Live: 430
Last Time Played Live: February 10, 2007 - Leon County Civic Center - Tallahassee, FL

(15) Woman Goin Crazy on Caroline Street:
http://www.buffettnews.com/song42.html

Written By: Jimmy Buffett & Steve Goodman

Discography:
Havana Daydreamin' (1976)
Live at Wrigley Field (2006)

Total Times Played Live: 43
Last Time Played Live: July 1, 2006 - Jones Beach Amphitheater, Wantagh, NY

Probably go down in flames, but I prefer women going crazy than fins.

I like the experience of Fins in concert. A high energy and fun song. My vote goes to Fins!

Tequila Revenge wrote:Probably go down in flames, but I prefer women going crazy than fins.

I think this is going to be close.

I love Woman Goin Crazy, but there's nothing like seeing Fins live in concert.

I can't choose. Fins is so fun, but heard it so much. Caroline Street is a big favorite!

SMLCHNG wrote: I can't choose. Fins is so fun, but heard it so much. Caroline Street is a big favorite!

I agree. I love Caroline Street, but Fins is probably the quintessential Buffett song.

SMLCHNG wrote: I can't choose. Fins is so fun, but heard it so much. Caroline Street is a big favorite!

This is the toughest choice so far.
I can't decide.

Oh this one is BAAAAD - I love WGCOCS but one of my favorite moments at any concert is watching thousands of people doing FINS. I think I have to vote for it based on that alone. And as someone else said it is a quintessential Jimmy song.

Tequila Revenge wrote:Probably go down in flames, but I prefer women going crazy than fins.

I have to go with Fins....it embodies the universal greeting of parrotheads everywhere...

I'm sorry, I'll always have my fins up, but Woman going crazy is a muchos better song!

How is Woman goin crazy on caroline street a 15 seed?!?!??!

I'm in the minority. Fins is great fun....but it's WGCOCS for me!

Ballads?

This one might be closer than the experts think. But based on concert experience, overall fun, my vote goes to the FIN.

Closer than I expected.

How is Fins a 2 seend and Caoline Street is in the teens?

Come on old Key West style. Chastise me if you will, but honestly, at this point I can do without Fins.

This should of been a 8-9 game!!!.....I personally like both songs a lot...but since i hear Fins all the time ..I voted for WGC!!

drunkpirate66 wrote:How is Fins a 2 seend and Caoline Street is in the teens?

Come on old Key West style. Chastise me if you will, but honestly, at this point I can do without Fins.

All of the songs were ranked based on the number of times that Jimmy has played them in concert. Fins is at almost every concert, whereas Caroline is more of a select choice

ejr wrote:

SMLCHNG wrote: I can't choose. Fins is so fun, but heard it so much. Caroline Street is a big favorite!

I agree. I love Caroline Street, but Fins is probably the quintessential Buffett song.

quintessential is a good word! Had to go with (\ FINS! /)