BuffettNews.com

No, it hasn't happened yet (but watch next year). But, who would you choose to replace Paula on American Idol?

A few loose rules for nomination...
1) Has to be a woman
2) Has to be a "has-been", preferably from the 80s.
3) May or may not be a minority

My nominations would be Debbie Gibson or Taylor Dayne.

I'm sure I'll come up with more, but wanted to throw this out there since they really need to get rid of that dingbat.

Oh, and Carnie Wilson, she's been on every other reality show it seems, so why not on AI.

How about Cindi Lauper (sp?)

Tiffany

Erin Moran

Since it's supposed to be at least partially about music shouldn't they have a judge who has, or at one time had, at least an ounce of musical talent in their body?

LIPH wrote:Since it's supposed to be at least partially about music shouldn't they have a judge who has, or at one time had, at least an ounce of musical talent in their body?

Nahhh, Paula doesn't.

LIPH wrote:Since it's supposed to be at least partially about music shouldn't they have a judge who has, or at one time had, at least an ounce of musical talent in their body?

You're saying Corey Clark had no musical talent?

chippewa wrote:

LIPH wrote:Since it's supposed to be at least partially about music shouldn't they have a judge who has, or at one time had, at least an ounce of musical talent in their body?

You're saying Corey Clark had no musical talent?

I guess Paula did have a musical bone in her body (at least for a few minutes).

blackjack wrote:

chippewa wrote:

LIPH wrote:Since it's supposed to be at least partially about music shouldn't they have a judge who has, or at one time had, at least an ounce of musical talent in their body?

You're saying Corey Clark had no musical talent?

I guess Paula did have a musical bone in her body (at least for a few minutes).

my guess her musical skills lie in her ability to dance the horizontal limbo.

I am thinking that Mindy McCready would be a choice right now - bet Roger Clemens would vote for her!!

Or how about Kim Carnes or Bonnie Tyler.

Maybe Salt or Pepa!

As long as it is not another N'Sync castoff!!!!!!!!

cdnkeywest wrote:As long as it is not another N'Sync castoff!!!!!!!!

Nope, it has to be a girl...and in NSync, only Lance Bass comes close.

(oh no he didn't!)

parrothead3282 wrote:How about Cindi Lauper (sp?)

I think this would be a good choice.

Ehhh Cyndi Lauper is so damn annoying with her accent....blah!

Belinda Carlisle

I don't think Simon would allow Paula to be replaced, I think he's got the hots for her.

How about Bret Michaels? He could bring some of those bimbos from his other show along...

It's going to be on ANOTHER year? Say it ain't so!

I'm so sick of notanywhereclosetoreality tv. I don't watch AI, but I am subjected to whatever the scandal du jour is on every other program I watch.

Ru Paul.

buffettbride wrote:Ru Paul.

Now THAT I might watch!