We all understand that there are many BN'ers and Parrotheads that don't like it when Jimmy covers someone else's song. And... I think I understand and appreciate the reasons behind that. However, Jimmy's selective use of cover songs on his albums and in his concerts does not bother me. I have my reasons. For purposes of this thread, could we perhaps try to focus on naming some cool buffett-ish songs that you wish Jimmy would cover? I have a few. Here are two:
MrTwain wrote:We all understand that there are many BN'ers and Parrotheads that don't like it when Jimmy covers someone else's song. And... I think I understand and appreciate the reasons behind that. However, Jimmy's selective use of cover songs on his albums and in his concerts does not bother me. I have my reasons. For purposes of this thread, could we perhaps try to focus on naming some cool buffett-ish songs that you wish Jimmy would cover? I have a few. Here are two:
Maria (Shut Up And Kiss Me) - Willie Nelson
What are your cover song ideas?
I have to pull a Nay Nay on this one. He royally messed up On The Road Again. If Jimmy was to even try to attempt Willie again, I think we would need to have to raise Johnny Cash and Waylon Jennings from the dead to make sure Jimmy never did this again.
Did you hear the one about me being a punk?
Did you hear the one about me being a drunk?
Did you hear the one about me losing my nerve?
Or how I'm just another f**** sheep in the herd?
Did you hear the one about me giving a s***?
Cause if I ever did I don't remember it.
Wino you know wrote:I can think of a few which I think he'd do a great cover version of, and would be aptly suited for him:
Captain Sunshine-NEIL DIAMOND
Oh man, that is a great suggestion and a fantastic song that I haven't listened to in years! I'm going to push my early Neil Diamond back into the iPod rotation.
Captain Sunshine, make me drink wine, Make me feel fine when I'm feelin' wrongly down.
He don't take much, he don't make much,
But ah, to be such a man as he,
and walk so pure between the earth and the sea.
Captain Sunshine, he do me fine, Make the words rhyme when he knows the tune is sad.
He don't take much, he don't make much,
But ah, to be such a man as he,
and walk so pure between the earth and the sea.
He don't take much, he don't make much,
But ah, to be such a man as he, and walk so pure between the earth and the sea.
Today I put in a Steve Goodman CD and when "Would You Like to Learn to Dance?" came on, I thought of this post. I think it'd be a great slow song (too few of those in most shows) or final acoustic encore.
That said, of course, I'd prefer to hear more of HIS old stuff
rich_big wrote:“Girl I Miss You”…..a rich_big original I have been playing for 15+ years. But it seems Jimmy ignores all the tapes I have sent him
It's so strange. You keep sending letters and tapes and all he ever sends back are reminder copies of the restraining order. It's like he's not even listening to it!
★ Maybe it's because in spite of all the work we do, it's the child in us we really value.
Why? I'd like to hear more original stuff...don't get me wrong, covers are great to get you going, but it seems like he has a cover or 7 on all his new stuff...when he releases new stuff.
I'd rather hear new original material than cover songs myself but if he can't do any better than some of the dribble he's come up with in recent years (Coast of Carolina not withstanding) then I'm fine with him doing songs by other artists, especially when it's the likes of Gillian Welch, Guy Clark, Mary Gauthier, Jesse Winchester, etc. The only thing is, when he used to cover folks like Jesse back in the day he stood a good chance of outdoing the original, now it's quite the opposite. Buffett's true knack now seems to be his writing (see his recent Outer Banks journal entries). I'd also rather see him do that than turn in subpar original material, though I could certainly do without the plugs for Landshark and Radio Margaritaville. His writing is good enough where he doesn't need to stoop to that level. When he does, it greatly detracts from it since it's totally unnecessary.
Last edited by Tiki Torches on January 15, 2009 11:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.