Yellow Submarine

tincupchalice · Post by **tincupchalice** » April 21, 2009 2:41 pm

Needs to be submerged in a lockbox and not be heard the rest of the tour, hate that it is taking up a key spot in the encore. Hopefully, it runs out of gas tonight..

dawgfan · Post by **dawgfan** » April 21, 2009 2:45 pm

I think the band sounds great with this cover, the all yellow lights on stage & the great back video. This song needs to stay, it is definitely good live. Sorry you can't get the full effect on RM.

HD18JBGuy · Post by **HD18JBGuy** » April 21, 2009 2:57 pm

tincupchalice wrote:Needs to be submerged in a lockbox and not be heard the rest of the tour, hate that it is taking up a key spot in the encore. Hopefully, it runs out of gas tonight..

Man, I completely know what your talking about. I can't stand the Beetles version of this song, let alone JB's cover. And, I agree with it taking up a key spot in the encore. Make it the opening song or something, but not the second to last song.

Unless the back video is clips from some wet T-shirt contest in Cancun during college spring break, then there won't be enough visual stimulation to keep me interested through this song.

RinglingRingling · Post by **RinglingRingling** » April 21, 2009 3:04 pm

This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.

Cincy'sOwnDrunk · Post by **Cincy'sOwnDrunk** » April 21, 2009 3:13 pm

I tend to agree with the author. This song sounded bad. Is not even close to being one of the Beatles better songs. While it may appear to be better live, my guess is that after a day of tailgating and the "coolness" of a Beatles song, thy judgement may not have been quite as clear cut. I know RM doesn't produce great sound, but this sounded very bad to me. Maybe after a few more times they will make it sound better, but I'm not sure it's a good song choice at all. If they insist on playing it, maybe they can put it in place of one of the other covers that they do. I mean, they do a great version of Southern Cross and Brown Eyed Girl, but haven't they done those enough already.

SchoolGirlHeart · Post by **SchoolGirlHeart** » April 21, 2009 3:19 pm

I didn't like it when I heard it on RM from Atlanta but I gave it a chance in Frisco because some songs don't translate well to RM. Sorry, Keith, I definitely had the opposite opinion; I didn't like it live, either. I'd much rather hear another Buffett song, but I'd even prefer Glory Days or Scarlet Begonias to Yellow Submarine.

HD18JBGuy · Post by **HD18JBGuy** » April 21, 2009 3:20 pm

RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.

"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.

SchoolGirlHeart · Post by **SchoolGirlHeart** » April 21, 2009 3:22 pm

HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.

I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.

HD18JBGuy · Post by **HD18JBGuy** » April 21, 2009 3:29 pm

SchoolGirlHeart wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.
I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.

Good point, it did get the crowd going, but like you, I didn't love it.

Since I have been playing guitar, I have realized just how many songs he does are cover songs. One day I will make a list of which songs are actually written by Jimmy vs. covered by Jimmy. Not that I mind his covered stuff, but many songs such as Defying Gravity, God's Own Drunk, Take the Weather With You, and Stories We Could Tell, to name a few, are all covers he did.

Cincy'sOwnDrunk · Post by **Cincy'sOwnDrunk** » April 21, 2009 3:37 pm

HD18JBGuy wrote:
SchoolGirlHeart wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.
I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.
Good point, it did get the crowd going, but like you, I didn't love it.

Since I have been playing guitar, I have realized just how many songs he does are cover songs. One day I will make a list of which songs are actually written by Jimmy vs. covered by Jimmy. Not that I mind his covered stuff, but many songs such as Defying Gravity, God's Own Drunk, Take the Weather With You, and Stories We Could Tell, to name a few, are all covers he did.

I thought this one was okay. At least it fits in with the scenery better and I didn't think it was performed that bad. Actually, just listened to it on the way home from work a little while ago. I was not a big fan of Glory Days either though. Of course, I'm not a big Springsteen fan which might have had a lot to do with it.

HD18JBGuy · Post by **HD18JBGuy** » April 21, 2009 3:44 pm

Cincy'sOwnDrunk wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
SchoolGirlHeart wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.
I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.
Good point, it did get the crowd going, but like you, I didn't love it.

Since I have been playing guitar, I have realized just how many songs he does are cover songs. One day I will make a list of which songs are actually written by Jimmy vs. covered by Jimmy. Not that I mind his covered stuff, but many songs such as Defying Gravity, God's Own Drunk, Take the Weather With You, and Stories We Could Tell, to name a few, are all covers he did.

I thought this one was okay. At least it fits in with the scenery better and I didn't think it was performed that bad. Actually, just listened to it on the way home from work a little while ago. I was not a big fan of Glory Days either though. Of course, I'm not a big Springsteen fan which might have had a lot to do with it.

Yeah, I saw him do Glory Days for the first time at Wrigley (second day show). It was a good way to end that show, but then when I saw it a few times after at other shows on the next tour, it wasn't as good. Then again, like you, not the biggest Springsteen fan, there are a lot of them.

UpstateNYPH · Post by **UpstateNYPH** » April 21, 2009 3:47 pm

Take out Yellow Submarine please (for Camden and AC at least).

Dezdmona · Post by **Dezdmona** » April 21, 2009 3:51 pm

MJM loved it, and is still singing it, 4 days after the show!

LivingOutMy2ndChance · Post by **LivingOutMy2ndChance** » April 21, 2009 4:19 pm

I'm not a huge Beatles fan or anything, but I liked it live (in ATL). And, for my money, it beats Glory Days any day of the week!

VanillaGrl · Post by **VanillaGrl** » April 21, 2009 4:24 pm

It didn't seem to make a difference... whether over the radio waves or live - I still didn't like it. Sorry..I just don't think it works for Jimmy and the band. But there are very few Beatle's covers that I do like...sooo...that's just my opinion. If they enjoy doing it... let 'em do it. I'll still be out there dancin' my fool a$$ off.

RinglingRingling · Post by **RinglingRingling** » April 21, 2009 4:31 pm

SchoolGirlHeart wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.
I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.

I wonder why...

I stick with my first statement: the Dylan cover (while the audience loved shouting out, "everybody must get stoned...") and now Yellow Submarine are 3-5 minute slots that could be filled with a Buffett written/recorded song. Hell, a live cut of "Here We Are" with Billy Payne backing Utley on keyboards would be incredible and a lot better use of the time.

VanillaGrl · Post by **VanillaGrl** » April 21, 2009 4:48 pm

RinglingRingling wrote:
SchoolGirlHeart wrote:
HD18JBGuy wrote:
RinglingRingling wrote:This is sorta like the Dylan cover last year... take the slot and use one of Jimmy's lesser-known, equally-upbeat-sounding songs.
"Everybody Must Get Stoned" was the one right? I agree with you on that too...it just didn't work for some reason.
I *really* disliked this one, too (Rainy Day Women). And yet I had to grudgingly admit that it got the crowd going and they seemed to love it, so I understood why it stayed in the show even though I didn't care for it.
I wonder why... I stick with my first statement: the Dylan cover (while the audience loved shouting out, "everybody must get stoned...") and now Yellow Submarine are 3-5 minute slots that could be filled with a Buffett written/recorded song. Hell, a live cut of "Here We Are" with Billy Payne backing Utley on keyboards would be incredible and a lot better use of the time.

Totally agree!

Cincy'sOwnDrunk · Post by **Cincy'sOwnDrunk** » April 21, 2009 4:54 pm

I could think of a lot better use of time for half the concert if truth be told........

aeroparrot · Post by **aeroparrot** » April 21, 2009 6:13 pm

Nah, don't want to hear this live, unless I'm at a concert by Ringo Starr and/or Paul McCartney. Otherwise, no one else does it any justice.

Capttony · Post by **Capttony** » April 21, 2009 6:45 pm

really hope he leaves this off the list. It's worse than the Dylan cover.

BuffettNews.com

Yellow Submarine

Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine

Re: Yellow Submarine