My fiancee and I are going to Sanibel Island for a long weekend over New Year's Eve. Looking forward to several days of doing very little!
We're wondering which of the restaurants on Sanibel or Captiva might be a fun place to ring in the New Year at midnight. Any suggestions?
Thanks!
Sanibel Island New Year's Eve
Moderator: SMLCHNG
-
Catch&Release
- Havana Daydreamin'
- Posts: 816
- Joined: December 14, 2005 8:29 am
- Number of Concerts: 0
- Location: Grand Haven, MI
Sanibel Island New Year's Eve
I don't want to live on that kind of island
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.
I don't know if they are planning anything big but I would check with the Tarpon Lodge in Pineland.
I live in Ft Myers and can tell you that Tarpon lodge is the neatest vacation property in SW Florida. They are an old 1940's lodge that has been renovated but still maintains its charm, that sits right on Pine Island sound. The food is top notch and they have a cool, dark wood paneled bar that will searve anything you may want including great Bloody marys for breakfast.
It is off the beaten path and not on Sanibel but take from a local, it is way more "old Florida" than anything Sanibel can cook up.
I live in Ft Myers and can tell you that Tarpon lodge is the neatest vacation property in SW Florida. They are an old 1940's lodge that has been renovated but still maintains its charm, that sits right on Pine Island sound. The food is top notch and they have a cool, dark wood paneled bar that will searve anything you may want including great Bloody marys for breakfast.
It is off the beaten path and not on Sanibel but take from a local, it is way more "old Florida" than anything Sanibel can cook up.
-
MacPhin
- Behind Door #3
- Posts: 3653
- Joined: March 22, 2004 9:16 pm
- Favorite Buffett Song: Anything BUT Cheeseburger
- Favorite Boat Drink: PainKiller
- Location: wish'in where every day of the year could be June
tarpon lodge is fun. you may run into our favorite author, randy wayne white ( whom we met a few times)there. he's buddies with the owners.however, getting there by anthing other than a boat, from sanibel is a long drive.
you could go to randy's place called, doc ford's sanibel rum bar. it's on the corner of san -cap road and i believe rabbit road.
or try the bar side ( crow's nest ) of 'tween waters on captiva. they always have something going on. i would call there first because it may require a reservation. we have had a blast there.
you could go to randy's place called, doc ford's sanibel rum bar. it's on the corner of san -cap road and i believe rabbit road.
or try the bar side ( crow's nest ) of 'tween waters on captiva. they always have something going on. i would call there first because it may require a reservation. we have had a blast there.

JB on Anguilla 3/24/07 St.Barth's 11/7/09
Lately,newspaper mentioned cheap airfare.
I've got to fly to Saint Somewhere.
I'm close to bodily harm.
-
SMLCHNG
- Moderator

- Posts: 178644
- Joined: December 6, 2001 7:00 pm
- Favorite Buffett Song: Tin Cup Chalice/Lovely Cruise
- Number of Concerts: 20
- Favorite Boat Drink: Rum Runner
- Location: Castle Rock, CO
You're correct!!MacPhin wrote: doc ford's sanibel rum bar. it's on the corner of san -cap road and i believe rabbit road.
http://www.mapquest.com/maps/map.adp?se ... =Get%2BMap
http://www.docfordssanibel.com/

-
ColdWaterConch
- If we weren't all crazy ...
- Posts: 559
- Joined: July 25, 2003 3:47 pm
- Number of Concerts: 0
- Location: Pittsburgh, PA (Key West transplant...ugh)
Re: Doc Fords....they used to have a rum sampler which was a 3 rum flight of top shelf rum. They stopped advertising this about 1-2 years ago. However, if you happen to run into the manager, and ask nicely, he will hook you up with a tremendous flight of very healthy pours...gave me one for $10 last summer. I could not drive home after it.
For New Years Eve, I would suggest The Mucky Duck on Anne Rosse Lane. Go to Captiva, and take a left at the stop sign (LOL). They have an evening Sunset Celebration that is pretty good (not Mallory Square good, but still nice...at least here you can wander into the GOM with a boat drink in hand). I'm sure they will have a New Years Eve party.
BTW, I'm jealous.
For New Years Eve, I would suggest The Mucky Duck on Anne Rosse Lane. Go to Captiva, and take a left at the stop sign (LOL). They have an evening Sunset Celebration that is pretty good (not Mallory Square good, but still nice...at least here you can wander into the GOM with a boat drink in hand). I'm sure they will have a New Years Eve party.
BTW, I'm jealous.
"Key West trades in on the name 'Hemingway." You can't take a leak without seeing Hemingway this and Hemingway that. And the irony is, if Hemingway were alive today he'd take a blowtorch to Duvall Street." Hiaasen
-
Catch&Release
- Havana Daydreamin'
- Posts: 816
- Joined: December 14, 2005 8:29 am
- Number of Concerts: 0
- Location: Grand Haven, MI
Thanks!
Thanks, everyone. We had a great time. We tried Doc Ford's the night before New Years Eve. It was great. I didn't get the rum sampler b/c I was driving. I did have one of their Mojitos which was excellent.
We had a great New Years Eve. During the day we kayaked around Buck Key. We even saw two manatees when we got back to the marina.
New Years Eve we were able to get a table at Timbers where our New Years Eve meal was excellent. They had Perrier Jouet Fleur champagne which we had last New Years Eve when we got engaged so we splurged and had it again this year. I had fried oysters and my fiancee had a petite filet and both were outstanding.
We had a great, great weekend.
Happy New Year!
We had a great New Years Eve. During the day we kayaked around Buck Key. We even saw two manatees when we got back to the marina.
New Years Eve we were able to get a table at Timbers where our New Years Eve meal was excellent. They had Perrier Jouet Fleur champagne which we had last New Years Eve when we got engaged so we splurged and had it again this year. I had fried oysters and my fiancee had a petite filet and both were outstanding.
We had a great, great weekend.
Happy New Year!
I don't want to live on that kind of island
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.
-
Catch&Release
- Havana Daydreamin'
- Posts: 816
- Joined: December 14, 2005 8:29 am
- Number of Concerts: 0
- Location: Grand Haven, MI
We didn't get a chance to fish. We were in during high tide and didn't see any feeding redfish. We did see an osprey grab what was either a small sea trout or a large mullett. We also saw a frigate bird which was neat as I'd never seen one outside of the Carribean.
I don't want to live on that kind of island
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.
No, I don't want to swim in a roped off sea.
Too much for me, too much for me
I've got to be where the wind and the water are free.