BuffettNews.com

Posted: **March 6, 2008 9:48 am**

creeky wrote:Well I am sure it is probably just an aussie media beatup .. but they are saying that Michael is now one of the favourites?

I gotta say - he sure is darn cute!!!!!!!

I would say he is about third best for the guys. David A. and David C. are ahead of him right now. I liked him early, but he seems to keep doing the same thing and not mixing it up much.

Posted: **March 6, 2008 8:59 pm**

Well, you think a lot of people are listening to Simon?

Posted: **March 6, 2008 10:00 pm**

Angel Beech wrote:Well, you think a lot of people are listening to Simon?

I kinda think so.. I agree with all those who were voted off tonight.

Posted: **March 6, 2008 10:31 pm**

creeky wrote:Well I am sure it is probably just an aussie media beatup .. but they are saying that Michael is now one of the favourites?

He's one of my faves, I know that! I think he's one of the best men this year.

I only disagreed with one of the vote-offs tonight and that was Asajha (or however you spell her name.......the girl who's dad died before her audition). I really liked her. But that's JMO.

Danny (or "Danjaya" as my husband called him) definitely needed to go!!

Posted: **March 6, 2008 10:33 pm**

CUparrot wrote: I only disagreed with one of the vote-offs tonight and that was Asajha (or however you spell her name.......the girl who's dad died before her audition). I really liked her. But that's JMO.

Danny (or "Danjaya" as my husband called him) definitely needed to go!!

Yeah, between the last two girls, it was a toss up, just based on last nights song.. but I like "Aisa" (not the spelling) better ..

Posted: **March 6, 2008 10:39 pm**

SMLCHNG wrote:
CUparrot wrote: I only disagreed with one of the vote-offs tonight and that was Asajha (or however you spell her name.......the girl who's dad died before her audition). I really liked her. But that's JMO.

Danny (or "Danjaya" as my husband called him) definitely needed to go!!
Yeah, between the last two girls, it was a toss up, just based on last nights song.. but I like "Aisa" (not the spelling) better ..

I really liked her personality......she has a certain spark to her. And I have to admit, the whole father dying story tugged at my heart strings so I was hoping she would go really far. Kristy's not bad--I don't think she'll win it all, but she's got a good voice.

Posted: **March 6, 2008 10:48 pm**

CUparrot wrote: I really liked her personality......she has a certain spark to her. And I have to admit, the whole father dying story tugged at my heart strings so I was hoping she would go really far. Kristy's not bad--I don't think she'll win it all, but she's got a good voice.

Exactly how I felt, too.

Posted: **March 6, 2008 11:12 pm**

blackjack wrote:None of the girls have WOWED me yet. I completely agree with Simon's assessment, "The guys were much better than the girls although the girls had 2-3 good performances tonight."

BUT, they liked Amanda tonight and I didn't think it was a "singer's song" and she mostly shouted...one trick pony.

I though Carly was good, probably my fave girl.

I was really rooting for KLC early on, but she hasn't nailed anything except Amazing Grace...she's been good, but not great.

Kady...awful, goodbye.

Ramiele...eh, take her or leave her, don't care.

Asia'h...low rent Syesha...she could go.

Syesha...good singer, but don't these girls know not to sing Whitney?

Brooke was good and Simon said what I was thinking...the only one to take a chance and play with the song as compared to several of the guys last night.

pat, pat...that's me patting myself on the back for picking all the discards male and female although I thought "Danjaya" (good one) might stay only because votefortheworst.com was pulling for him.

I agree 100% with the discards. Way to go Simon!

Posted: **March 7, 2008 12:40 am**

This year song selection is key and America is listening to Simon, which usually happens during this time, so we are now down the the 12. My thoughts, the final will be Danny A vs Carly. Danny A did not do well last week, so I am a tiny bit worried about my prediction.

I really like Mike, Jason and Brooke, too.

Posted: **March 7, 2008 6:44 am**

SMLCHNG wrote:I agree with all those who were voted off tonight.

Surprisingly, I did too. That rarely if ever happens. However, Amanda needs to go soon. Her voice is painful for me to listen to. She sounds like she just smoked a pack backstage and is hacking it up.

And it doesn't have as much to do with his vocals, but I can't watch David H. anymore without thinking about him lap-dancing naked on some dude.

Posted: **March 9, 2008 12:20 am**

Just watched the guys show from last week (we get all shows for the week on Sunday)

I have to say I did like michaels performance the best ... good aussie boy singing a good aussie song ... not that I am biased ... but the genre of his song suited me better.

I am happy with the two guys that went - Danny - he freaked me out a little ... so was there more to the comment "come out" than in regards to his singing

Posted: **March 11, 2008 8:56 pm**

BTT
halfway through the show:
Chikezie threw down some Zydeco!
Carly ROCKED!!!
David Cook knows how to bring some modern-day rock to a classic. WOW.

Posted: **March 11, 2008 10:11 pm**

I still like the dredlocked kid, and David Cook. Stripper boy was pretty weak though, and sounded like such a total moron in his interview clip.
I missed Kristy Lee, but from what I saw of the re-cap she was lame too.

And I still just don't get Amanda!!!

Posted: **March 11, 2008 10:20 pm**

I'm a HUGE fan of the songwriters they chose to showcase tonight.....I won't mention who for those who have not watched yet....so I was very much a critic......

I didn't like any of them except Carly and Brooke was so so.

Posted: **March 11, 2008 11:18 pm**

I love the Beatles music tonight, will give my thoughts later, cause some of you are still watching the show.

Posted: **March 11, 2008 11:20 pm**

This was the first night I really enjoyed the show ... loved the music ... even the ones the judges panned sounded okay to me ... even though I was so in love with George, the songs John and Paul wrote are still stunning, all these years later. ~Sigh~

Posted: **March 12, 2008 2:31 am**

IMHO:
Kristy Lee Cook and David Hernandez will probably be leaving.
Wrong song choices, & they couldn't pull it off.

Posted: **March 12, 2008 3:48 am**

OttoCal wrote:I still like the dredlocked kid, and David Cook. Stripper boy was pretty weak though, and sounded like such a total moron in his interview clip.
I missed Kristy Lee, but from what I saw of the re-cap she was lame too.

And I still just don't get Amanda!!!

the dreds guy would be quite good looking if he got a decent hair cut

Amanda just scares me!!!

Posted: **March 12, 2008 8:06 am**

Angel Beech wrote:IMHO:
Kristy Lee Cook and David Hernandez will probably be leaving.
Wrong song choices, & they couldn't pull it off.

David H. just BUTCHERED that song!

I definitely did NOT like the country twist to "Eight Days a Week."

Of course......rocker Amanda s*cked......plus she sort of scares me!

Posted: **March 12, 2008 8:06 am**

Carly did the best by far.....IMHO!

BuffettNews.com

American Idol 2008 *New poll ~ Winner?*

American Idol 2008 New poll ~ Winner?