Page 1 of 4

Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:15 pm
by Tiki Torches
From The Tennessean:

Image
Peter Cooper is the senior music writer and columnist for The Tennessean.

by Peter Cooper

To most every male country singer I’ve heard on the radio this morning.....

First, I’m on your side. I’m rooting for you.

I think we’ve got a lot in common. We probably like a lot of the same music.

But I don’t believe you.

All day, you’ve been singing rock songs to me about how country you are. And even country songs about how country you are. It’s been “dirt road” this and “back road” that, and “party in the woods” this and “redneck, hillbilly” that.

Then there’s been some stuff about fishing with cane poles, and skinny-dipping in the lake with some two-named girl. Was it Betty Sue? Wanda Lou?

And I don’t believe you were on the dirt road to the barn party with your redneck, hillbilly friends. I don’t believe the story about the lake. I don’t even believe anyone under the age of 30 is named Wanda.

I know there are probably exceptions, but I will not be considering them on a case-by-case basis. I don’t know why we’re so adamant about all of this, anyway. Why should I be interested that you’re so proud of where you say you’re from? Wasn’t it kind of an accident of birth?

Anyway, I like where I’m from just fine, but it wasn’t exactly my idea. It just sort of happened that way. And I could write a song about where I’m from — the Palmetto State of South Carolina — and make it chock-full of country references and stuff about the cradle of the Confederacy and the buckle of the Bible Belt, about tobacco fields and whacky politicians (I guess I’d leave out that last part).

But the truth is, you and I are from exactly the same place. We’re from the home pretty near the interstate exit. You know the exit: The one with the Waffle House and the Sonic and the Applebees, close to the big box retail store.

Ah, the stuff of great country songs. Perhaps I’ll write an up-tempo number, bragging about how I’m from one of the toughest suburbs in Columbia, S.C. Folks, you didn’t want to mess with the Gardendale boys if you crossed over the wrong side of Pine Forest Trail.

Anyway, you and I, if our necks are red, it’s not from plowing the fields, it’s from leaning out the driver’s window on a hot summer day to place our onion ring order at the Sonic.

There exists a grand country music tradition of writing about southern lifestyles, about good country people and bad country people and about the ways that common men and women bide their time, mourn and celebrate. I dig Hank Williams’ “Jambalaya” and Mel McDaniel’s “Louisiana Saturday Night” and Jason Aldean’s agrarian rumination, “Amarillo Sky.”

But this morning, most every male country singer on the radio, your antics have grown tiresome.

I’d rather be hit by a can of your favorite domestic beer than hear you name-check that beer one more time when you’re singing about the party in the woods that you know darn well the three people who wrote the song in a metropolitan Nashville office absolutely, for sure, did not attend.

I’m sorry, I’m unduly irritated. Truth is, I’m a little hung over from the big party out in the woods, down the dirt road. I don’t even remember the ride back home, so it’s a good thing Wanda Lou had the keys.

But I’ve heard your albums, most every male country singer. And I know you can deliver songs of substance, songs that speak even to the 99.9 percent of the earth’s population who would not describe themselves as rednecks or hillbillies. I know that you sing things that make people think and feel, that make people feel connected to each other by more than beer brands.

I also know that the hillbilly redneck party down in the country song is trending well on the radio stations these days. It’s summertime, and the youngsters are out of school (We remember those days, don’t we, most every male country singer?) and all over the South, radios are blaring and pickup trucks are gathering and the redneck kids are kicking it country-style.

In the parking lot.

At the Sonic.

Reach Peter Cooper at 615-259-8220 or pcooper@tennessean.com

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:19 pm
by springparrot
I like it!!!! :D

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:22 pm
by Tiki Torches
springparrot wrote:I like it!!!! :D
I prefer actual country music as opposed to someone's cliched, stereotypical, closed minded view of it but maybe that's just me.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:28 pm
by citcat
Does he not realize that those 'male country music stars' hardly ever write their own songs ? The songwriters are the ones who live the life. The 'male country music stars' mostly sing songs picked for them. Some are actual writers, though. I can think of one called Mac. 8) :lol:

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:39 pm
by surfpirate
The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:44 pm
by Tiki Torches
citcat wrote:Does he not realize that those 'male country music stars' hardly ever write their own songs ?


Since Peter Cooper is a well renown author (and sometime songwriter himself) who's based out of Nashville Im sure he's well aware of it. That's the crux of the article anyway, at least as I interpreted it.
citcat wrote:The songwriters are the ones who live the life.
That's not what I got out of the article. What I got out of it is that these songwriters aren't living the life they're singing about at all. They're coming up with cliched, hackneyed images that cater to the lowest common denominator in country music these days. It's what's selling records so these songs are full of stereotypical characters and scenarios because that is what sells records (unfortunately) to a large portion of the country music audience in 2011.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:50 pm
by maid memories
This is the argument I've been making since Gretchen Wilson made being white trash something to brag about. I've over the tractor songs.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 1:50 pm
by Tiki Torches
surfpirate wrote:The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".
I'll take the songwriting side of Buffett over the cheesey "trop rock" image some have of him any day of the week. That's probably a huge reason why I prefer artists such as Guy Clark, Lyle Lovett, Jerry Jeff Walker, John Prine, Steve Earle, Emmylou Harris, etc. over the Buffett imitators that are so popular among much of his fanbase.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 2:19 pm
by surfpirate
"Well I was drunk the day my mom got out of prison
And I went to pick her up in the rain
But before I could get to the station in my pickup truck
She got runned over by a dammed old train"

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 2:30 pm
by Tiki Torches
surfpirate wrote:"Well I was drunk the day my mom got out of prison
And I went to pick her up in the rain
But before I could get to the station in my pickup truck
She got runned over by a dammed old train"
David Allan Coe was also projecting an image (and continues to). That was a perfectly fine song before he added his bit to it.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 2:49 pm
by TommyBahama
Tiki Torches wrote:
surfpirate wrote:The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".
I'll take the songwriting side of Buffett over the cheesey "trop rock" image some have of him any day of the week. That's probably a huge reason why I prefer artists such as Guy Clark, Lyle Lovett, Jerry Jeff Walker, John Prine, Steve Earle, Emmylou Harris, etc. over the Buffett imitators that are so popular among much of his fanbase.
I don't think Chesney's Music sounds anything like Buffett....and i really don't consider him Trop Rock....is ZBB Trop rock, because he did a couple of songs with JB, and has a couple of songs with beach references.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 2:55 pm
by Tiki Torches
TommyBahama wrote:
Tiki Torches wrote:
surfpirate wrote:The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".
I'll take the songwriting side of Buffett over the cheesey "trop rock" image some have of him any day of the week. That's probably a huge reason why I prefer artists such as Guy Clark, Lyle Lovett, Jerry Jeff Walker, John Prine, Steve Earle, Emmylou Harris, etc. over the Buffett imitators that are so popular among much of his fanbase.
I don't think Chesney's Music sounds anything like Buffett....and i really don't consider him Trop Rock....is ZBB Trop rock, because he did a couple of songs with JB, and has a couple of songs with beach references.
I'm not sure what you would call the music of Kenny Chesney or the Zac Brown Band but what I have heard simply doesn't appeal to me. As for the article, it's speaking to the cliched images of what country music has become in recent years. Throw a few of the phrases Peter Cooper mentions in his piece together and you have the makings for a current hit country song, or at least what seems to have become representative of one.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 3:03 pm
by TommyBahama
Tiki Torches wrote:
TommyBahama wrote:
Tiki Torches wrote:
surfpirate wrote:The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".
I'll take the songwriting side of Buffett over the cheesey "trop rock" image some have of him any day of the week. That's probably a huge reason why I prefer artists such as Guy Clark, Lyle Lovett, Jerry Jeff Walker, John Prine, Steve Earle, Emmylou Harris, etc. over the Buffett imitators that are so popular among much of his fanbase.
I don't think Chesney's Music sounds anything like Buffett....and i really don't consider him Trop Rock....is ZBB Trop rock, because he did a couple of songs with JB, and has a couple of songs with beach references.
I'm not sure what you would call the music of Kenny Chesney or the Zac Brown Band but what I have heard simply doesn't appeal to me. As for the article, it's speaking to the cliched images of what country music has become in recent years. Throw a few of the phrases Peter Cooper mentions in his piece together and you have the makings for a current hit country song, or at least what seems to have become representative of one.
i guess we all have our opinions, and what music we like and dislike....all i see is 2 bands that are selling out stadiums and have #1 songs on the charts....so i guess someone likes there music. And they are marketing themselves pretty well.

and i agree with the article.....i'm sure they a lot don't live what they are singing about...Tim McGraws dad was a Baseball player....so i'm pretty sure he didn't live the same life as say a Toby Keith or a Geoge Straight!!!

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 3:05 pm
by Joetown Parrothead
I like ZBB a lot, also like Chesney.. I really like George Strait, Reba, Montgomery Gentry, Alan Jackson, Van Zandt, Toby Keith and Tim McGraw. I like some of Darrius Ruckers new stuff he is doing... I know some of the new artist do sound a lot alike, but it is the music factory at Nashville that just want to put out radio hits like Motown tried to do for ever... Oh well to each is own...


Have a great Monday everyone.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 3:14 pm
by Tiki Torches
Joetown Parrothead wrote:I like ZBB a lot, also like Chesney.. I really like George Strait, Reba, Montgomery Gentry, Alan Jackson, Van Zandt, Toby Keith and Tim McGraw. I like some of Darrius Ruckers new stuff he is doing... I know some of the new artist do sound a lot alike, but it is the music factory at Nashville that just want to put out radio hits like Motown tried to do for ever... Oh well to each is own...
It's not how the music sounds similar that Cooper is focusing on, it's the stereotypical image it projects of life in the country/rural areas that he's speaking to. It's as though the people writing the songs are taking the easy way out by concentrating on what they see as country music culture. Sure, there is lots of fishing, riding of four wheelers and pick up trucks, etc. but those have only become cliches that are all too easily marketed. It's the dumbing down of country music songwriting when there's much more to it than that. At least that is the gist I got out of the article.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 4:38 pm
by PA PAR8 HED
I'm not a huge country music fan, but I don't see it as that much different than the Buffett effect. In either case it is escapeism. And whether one would rather sit on a beach with a boat drink or party at the end of the dirt road with a can of domestic beer, sometimes we like our music to reflect that image, even if we don't really live that way.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 4:53 pm
by Anne Bonny
It probably shouldn't matter what life they lived. Their songs are entertainment not Gospel.

If they are off stage spouting stuff they can't back up, then it just makes them look stupid.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 5:05 pm
by Tiki Torches
Anne Bonny wrote:It probably shouldn't matter what life they lived. Their songs are entertainment not Gospel.
I think most everyone understands that, it's the perpetuation of a stereotype that Peter Cooper is calling into question with his article.

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 5:11 pm
by Anne Bonny
People are clinging to their stereotypes. It seems the more globalization spreads the more they loose their own sense of self. Weird isn't it?

Re: Country boys are wearing out calling cards

Posted: July 11, 2011 6:52 pm
by LIPH
Tiki Torches wrote:
surfpirate wrote:The exact same sentiments have been expressed about ZBB, Jimmy Buffett (latter day), trop rock et al etc. etc. and their beach, sun, tropical ways as well.

And I say "Who gives a rat's ass?".
I'll take the songwriting side of Buffett over the cheesey "trop rock" image some have of him any day of the week. That's probably a huge reason why I prefer artists such as Guy Clark, Lyle Lovett, Jerry Jeff Walker, John Prine, Steve Earle, Emmylou Harris, etc. over the Buffett imitators that are so popular among much of his fanbase.
To change the subject slightly, this is something I could never understand. Kenny Chesney does a "Buffett-type" song and people want to rip him a new blowhole because they think he's a Buffett wannabe. Yet, many of those same people get almost orgasmic talking about trop rock artists, who owe their careers to being Buffett wannabes. Not to mention Zac Brown, who does a couple of "Buffett-type" songs and people are talking about the guy like he's the greatest thing since chocolate milk. Things that make you go "hmmmmm".

We now return you to your regularly scheduled thread. :lol: